Choosing between Scotland or Ireland is one of the hardest travel decisions people make — not because one is better than the other, but because they offer very different travel experiences.

Both countries are English-speaking, safe, historic, and stunningly beautiful. But once you factor in driving distances, scenery variety, cities, food, and how much planning you want to do, the “better” choice becomes clearer.

I’ve traveled to both Scotland and Ireland multiple times, including with kids, and this guide breaks down the real differences that actually affect your trip — not just the highlights — so you can choose with confidence and avoid common planning mistakes.

I think for many people, Scotland and Ireland have a lot of similarities. Both countries are part of the British Isles and speak English, but they are not the same!

I have been asked multiple times which country is “better.”

That is an impossible question because they are each so unique, and everyone should visit both! But I know that it isn’t realistic for many people to do that, so let’s look at how they are similar and how they are different.

---

Scotland vs Ireland: Which One Is Right for You? (Quick Answer)

If you’re short on time, here’s the simplest way to decide between Scotland and Ireland:

Choose Scotland if you:

• Want dramatic scenery with mountains, lochs, and rugged coastlines

• Don’t mind longer driving days for big “wow” moments

• Love castles, history, and varied landscapes

• Want iconic views like the Highlands and Isle of Skye

Choose Ireland if you:

• Prefer shorter drives and a more relaxed pace

• Love food, pubs, live music, and charming towns

• Want more accommodation options and flexibility

• Enjoy green rolling hills and coastal scenery without extreme terrain

  ---

Scotland

Scotland is a part of Great Britain and is known for its rolling hills, lochs, and whisky. There are many unique cultural aspects to Scotland that are not part of Great Britain, such as a distinct accent, sports teams (like the Glasgow Rangers), and a traditional national dress called the kilt. Scotland

Scotland is also home to many great universities like Edinburgh University and St Andrews. It’s rich in history and ancient castles, such as Edinburgh Castle and Stirling Castle.

Parts of Scotland could easily be mistaken for the green hills of Ireland, but in addition, you will find tall mountains, flat lowlands, and the iconic Scottish Highlands.

Ireland

Ireland is a beautiful island nation in the British Isles that offers its own unique culture, music, and language. The Republic of Ireland is not part of the United Kingdom, while Northern Ireland is.

The Irish language (Gaelic) is still spoken in many parts of the country, and traditional music is a big part of life there. Ireland is known for its lush green landscape, rolling hills, and vibrant nightlife. It’s also home to some great universities, such as Trinity College Dublin and University College Dublin. It has many charming towns and villages and is also known for its pubs, which offer great music and a lively atmosphere.

Travel Logistics: Scotland vs Ireland (Driving, Transportation & Ease)

One of the biggest differences between Scotland and Ireland — and one that affects almost every itinerary — is how easy they are to get around.

Both countries offer clean, safe, and affordable public transportation, especially in major cities. Scotland has an extensive train network connecting cities like Edinburgh, Glasgow, and Inverness, while Ireland’s rail system connects Dublin to major regions like Galway and Cork.

That said, most visitors to both countries end up renting a car, especially if they want to see castles, countryside, and coastal areas.

Driving in both Scotland and Ireland means driving on the left side of the road, which can feel intimidating at first if you’re coming from North America. The good news is that most travelers adjust within a day or two.

Where the experience differs is road size and driving stress. Ireland’s roads are often much narrower, especially in rural areas where hedgerows line winding country lanes. Scotland’s roads are generally wider and easier to navigate, making it a better choice for nervous drivers or first-time international road trippers.

If you’re comfortable driving and want maximum flexibility, both countries work well — but if ease matters more than adventure, Ireland usually feels simpler.

Scotland vs. Ireland

We will be comparing the two beautiful countries in 12 different categories and will let you be the judge. (Although I am team “visit both”!)

 

Public Transportation in Scotland vs. Ireland

Scotland and Ireland both have public transportation with clean, safe, and affordable buses. In Scotland, you can use a bus pass on weekends as long as it is within the same region or travel outside of your area for £20 for an annual pass. You can also buy monthly passes in advance if you plan to hop onto the bus more than once per week!

 

Ireland does not have this option, but their prices are lower at €25 euros for one year, which is about $25 US dollars. (at the time of this writing. Please check the exchange rates! )The downside to Irish buses is that they don’t have designated bus lanes since the roads are narrower.

Prices to stay a week in each Scotland and Ireland

Scotland and Ireland offer competitive prices for flights, hotels, food shopping, and entertainment, but it really depends on what you want to do with your money! Prices for hotels in Scotland are about 115 pounds a night for one room; in Ireland, they are around $129. Please keep in mind these prices are for single occupancy! (Prices vary constantly, but this is an up-to-date average.)

 

You can find the best deals in Scotland if you plan ahead. Hotels outside of cities like Edinburgh or Glasgow usually cost less than hotels in major metropolitan areas, where prices start at £75 to stay overnight. In Dublin, however, it’s not uncommon that hotel rates rise to €150 per night during busy seasons—but there are often great deals online if you book well in advance.

 

Prices for a week for a family of 4 range from $2000- $4000 in Scotland and $1500-$3000 in Ireland.

 

Castles in Scotland vs. Ireland

 

If you love to visit castles, you will love Scotland and Ireland. There are more castles per capita in Scotland than in any other country, and in Ireland, you can find some of the most beautiful castles on Earth.

 

The types of castles are very different in each country. You can find many more stone castles in Scotland, and you will see Irish castles with their trademark round towers. They are both fascinating and beautiful.

 

In Ireland, the biggest castle is Dublin Castle, where visitors can explore over 120 acres of land! Scotland has two giant castles: Edinburgh Castle and Stirling Castle.

Visiting Castles in Ireland is something we have done several times and found that we preferred them to Scotland’s castles.

 

Where is the better scenery? Scotland or Ireland?

I would say Scotland has the better scenery. Ireland is green but not as varied in the landscape as Scotland. The greenest time to visit for either is from March to June when the grasses turn bright emerald hues with lush vegetation filling each valley.

 

But honestly, both are gorgeous! Scotland has more striking mountains and rugged coastlines vs. Ireland’s green hills and gorgeous vistas.

Both are spectacularly beautiful countries, and you won’t be disappointed with either.

Does Scotland or Ireland have better food?

 

Ireland has undergone something of a food renaissance.  Every time we visit, the food is better than the last time. Ireland has a lot more food variety than Scotland does, and in general, Ireland is just an eating destination. There are some traditional Irish foods that you simply must try while you are there, like, Irish Stew, Colcannon, and Barmbrack.

There are plenty of pubs to visit, but the Irish also have delicious pasties, pies, crisps (potato chips), or even cabbage rolls! And don’t forget about their famous beers too.

 

Scotland doesn’t really compare when it comes to food, but they do offer some yummy meat pies that come with pickled cucumbers on top and cheese curds, as well as Scottish shortbread which is a buttery biscuit dipped in sugar icing.

If you are brave like my ids are, you might want to try Haggis. But there are delicious desserts to be found like Cranachan, a  parfait with whipped cream, berries and oats, or Millionaire shortbread, kind of like a delcious Twix.

 

Where are the people most welcoming and helpful?

In terms of being welcoming, both countries are very friendly! Scottish and Irish people will be inviting if you want to chat about anything. If you need directions or help you will be happy to know that people in both countries are very helpful.

 

But if I had to pick one (and I’m not saying it has to be only one), Ireland is a bit more welcoming. The country itself has a better accommodation system with more hotels, hostels, B&Bs, etc., which can make booking easier or at least give you options. In Scotland, there aren’t as many choices, so book early!

 

Busiest Time Of Year in Scotland and Ireland

If crowds of people make you feel uncomfortable, you are in luck! Even the busy times of year for Scotland and Ireland don’t feel nearly as busy as other European countries.

The busiest time period for Scottish tourism starts at Easter – June- September, while Ireland’s peak tourism lasts between April – October.

 

If you choose to travel in the off-season, you can find some amazing deals for hotels and car rentals, but check before you book because some of the castles won’t be open.

 

Driving on the left side

 

In both Scotland and Ireland, you will need to be prepared to drive on the left side of the street!

Driving on the left side of the street is overwhelming if you are from North America. I did not know what I was getting myself into when we drove to Ireland. The first time you drive on the left side of the street is a bit harrowing, but it doesn’t take long to get used to, and after that, it feels just like home!

 

Ireland has much narrower streets than Scotland due to hedgerows on each side of tiny winding streets, so if you are a very nervous driver, Scotland might be better for you!

 

Driving on the left side of the street does not stop there. In Ireland, when driving in a roundabout (or rotary), all vehicles must “go left,” which is quite confusing for first-time drivers.

 

Just take it slow, and you will be like a pro driving in Ireland or Scotland by day two!

 

Flight prices to Scotland vs. Ireland

Prices for flights to Scotland and Ireland are pretty interchangeable from big East Coast cities. Overall, I find cheaper flights to Dublin or Shannon Airports than to Edinburgh.

 

You can find cheap flights from Stewart Airport to Ireland if you live near NYC. We have flown to Scotland via Dublin and taken advantage of cheap Ryan Air flights to make our flights cheaper.

Find your cheapest flights to Ireland here!

 

Weather in Scotland vs. Ireland

Ireland is a little more temperate with less extreme weather than Scotland and has really nice summers when they are not too overcast or rainy. For the most part, the summer months will be sunny, but it can get quite chilly at night so pack accordingly!

On the other hand, Scotland doesn’t have a great summer season, but the weather is often pleasant, and if you are lucky, it won’t rain. Inverness, Aberdeen, etc., make sure you bring your rain gear because it does rain there year-round. It often rains (not just during winter) and usually heavily rather than drizzling all day long

The temperatures stay fairly consistent from season to season, making traveling easier.

 

Does Scotland or Ireland have better cities?

Scotland:

Edinburgh – It’s an old city with lots of history, heritage, and beautiful architecture! There are plenty of places to explore, including museums, parks, gardens, castles (you can even drink at one!), historic buildings, live music venues & more. When exploring Edinburgh, make sure to take in the view from Arthur’s Seat-a hill that overlooks all of Edinburgh. If you want something green, visit Falkirk National Park, which is only 45 minutes away by car or train from Edinburgh.

Glasgow – Glasgow has many modern facilities like shopping malls, cinemas, great music venues, parks, and museums. Glasgow has a bit of everything for everyone!

Highlands of Scotland– the stunning landscapes in the Highlands of Scotland will never disappoint!

Inverness– Inverness is a quaint city with beautiful views and loads of history. There are many places to explore, see attractions, or visit festivals like Highland Games

St. Andrews – an old coastal town with a rich heritage and golfing options (the Old Course at St. Andrews is one of the most famous courses in the world)!

Perth– Perth is quite different from other cities because it’s set on estuaries, so there isn’t much green scenery but instead more urban scenes like banks and shops. It still offers diverse cultures, though, notably Chinese New Year celebrations every January, which often include fire dragons dancing around the main street.

Isle of Skye– Isle of Skye may be the most beautiful spot in all of Scotland. It is known for its dramatic landscapes and has the most spectacular coastline in Scotland.

Dundee– Dundee is a small city, but it’s also one of the country’s biggest cities! You can explore all types of cultural heritage, like Dudhope Park, which encompasses green spaces and wetlands, including an adjacent wetland reserve.

 

Ireland:

Dublin – Dublin is a very modern and contemporary city. It has many shopping opportunities with places like Brown Thomas, Iveagh Garden Shopping Centre & more. If you’re looking for something green, then head down to the Phoenix Park in Dublin, which is also home to many landmarks, including Croke Park, where all Gaelic sports are played

West Cork– West Cork is great if you want to get away from it all because it’s not touristy! Many beautiful beaches and rocks make up this region, and scenic drives along the coastline.

Galway– Galway is located on the coast in the western part of Ireland. It has a very picturesque town with many cafes, pubs, and restaurants, as well as traditional Irish music playing throughout to make it feel more festive.

Dingle Peninsula-The Dingle Peninsula is a small part of Ireland and has many tourist attractions. It’s known for its scenic views, making you feel like the only one there!

 

Scotland vs. Ireland, which is more family-friendly?

Scotland and Ireland are family-friendly, but they are different in that Ireland is more of a party scene.  (At least in the cities.) Ireland seems to have more festivals, clubs, and pubs than Scotland.

But both a great family vacation destinations. There are plenty of things to do with your kids in each country.

Both have tons of things for kids to do and kids’ meals at most restaurants.

Here is how to do 4 days in Ireland with your kids to help you make a decision.

Hotels in Scotland vs. Ireland

Hotels are similar in both countries. Both countries have hotels all over the country. However, in Ireland, you will find more large chain-based hotels that might be better for families or people looking for something they are already familiar with. Ireland does have a lot of Airbnbs and VRBOs everywhere you go!

Plus you can stay in a castle hotel in Ireland!

 

Scotland has many “B&Bs” that offer great personal service and care to their guests. You can find some amazing B&Bs at reasonable rates, though!

For those looking for something a little different and who enjoy the personal touch, trying out Scotland’s B&Bs is worth it! You will find many that offer all you need, plus they are often cheaper than hotels with even better service! Plus if your trip includes children, there are some great places to stay at where they can play outside safely or do arts and crafts while you relax nearby, reading or working from home.

Which is Safer?

Both countries are very safe with some of the lowest crime rates in the world. The most dangerous spot we went was to Phoenix Park in Dublin. The kids were eating sandwiches and the deer wanted a taste!

However make good choices when you are traveling. Don’t be in isolated places at night, don’t carry an easy to steal purse, and if you feel uncomfortable anywhere, leave.

How Many Days Do You Need in Scotland vs Ireland?

Time is one of the biggest deciding factors when choosing between Scotland and Ireland.

If you have 4–5 days, Ireland is usually the better option. You can base yourself in one or two locations, enjoy the countryside, visit a few towns, and still have time to relax without spending hours in the car.

With 7–10 days, Scotland really shines. While you can visit Scotland in less time, the country’s size and scenery mean longer drives are common, especially if you want to see the Highlands or Isle of Skye. A week gives you enough time to experience both cities and landscapes without rushing.

If you have 10 days or more, either country works beautifully — and this is when Scotland’s variety really stands out, while Ireland allows for deeper exploration of multiple regions.

Travel Logistics: Scotland vs Ireland (Driving, Distance & Ease)

One of the most practical differences between Scotland and Ireland is how easy they are to navigate.

Both countries have reliable public transportation in major cities, but most travelers rent a car to see castles, countryside, and coastal areas. Driving is on the left side of the road in both places, which can feel intimidating at first but becomes manageable quickly.

Where they differ is road size and pacing. Ireland’s rural roads are often very narrow, with hedgerows lining winding lanes, which can feel stressful for nervous drivers. Scotland’s roads are generally wider and better marked, making them easier to handle — even though distances between destinations are often longer.

If you want a trip that feels simpler and more forgiving, Ireland is usually easier. If you’re comfortable driving and want maximum scenic payoff, Scotland delivers.

Which Is Better for First-Time Visitors: Scotland or Ireland?

For first-time international travelers, Ireland often feels more approachable.

Ireland’s compact size, abundance of accommodations, and shorter driving distances make it easier to plan without overthinking every detail. Many travelers find Ireland less overwhelming for a first European road trip.

Scotland, while still very friendly and easy to navigate, benefits from more advance planning. Choosing the right bases and pacing matters more, especially if you want to include the Highlands or islands.

If this is your first trip abroad or you want something low-stress, Ireland is usually the better introduction. If you’re comfortable planning routes and enjoy dramatic landscapes, Scotland is an unforgettable first choice.

Cost of a Trip: Scotland vs Ireland (Where Your Money Goes Further)

Scotland and Ireland are similar in overall travel costs, but how your money stretches can feel very different.

Ireland generally has more accommodation options — hotels, B&Bs, Airbnbs — which makes it easier to find something within your budget, especially for families. Food prices in Ireland are also quite reasonable given the quality.

Scotland can be excellent value if you plan ahead, but accommodations outside major cities book quickly and choices can be more limited. That means good planning saves money, while last-minute bookings can get expensive.

Neither country is “cheap,” but Ireland often feels more flexible, while Scotland rewards thoughtful planning with incredible value.

Best Time to Visit Scotland vs Ireland (Weather & Crowds)

Weather plays a bigger role in travel experience in Scotland and Ireland than many people expect.

The best time to visit both countries is late spring through early fall. From May to September, days are long, landscapes are lush, and attractions are fully open.

Ireland tends to have slightly milder weather, while Scotland can feel cooler — especially in the Highlands — with rain possible year-round. That said, Scotland’s dramatic scenery often looks its best under moody skies.

Both countries are busiest during summer, but even peak season crowds feel manageable compared to other European destinations. Traveling in the shoulder season can offer better prices and fewer people, with only minor trade-offs.

Final Verdict: Scotland or Ireland?

If I had to choose just one country to visit again, I would personally choose Scotland — mainly for the dramatic scenery and variety of landscapes.

That said, Ireland is often the easier first trip, especially for travelers who want shorter drives, more flexible lodging, and a food-forward experience.

The truth is: most travel regrets don’t come from choosing the wrong country — they come from trying to do too much, driving too far, or staying in the wrong places.

 

If you feel differently, please let me know why!

No matter which country you visit, you will have a wonderful time! I hope this has helped narrow down the best fit for you and your family.

 

Want help planning once you’ve chosen?

I’ve created family-tested itineraries for both Scotland and Ireland that map out realistic driving distances, where to stay, and what’s actually worth seeing — so you don’t have to piece it together yourself.

 Start here:

• One Week in Scotland (realistic route + bases)

• Ireland With Kids (paced for families)

• Ireland Road Trip Itinerary

 

Check out our itineraries for Ireland and Scotland below:

 

Ireland with the kids

Ireland for a honeymoon

One week in Scotland

 

Ireland scotland